Ana's vs Home Depot Adirondack chair

Submitted by stuch428 on Wed, 11/19/2014 - 07:55

Was wondering if anyone had made either of these chairs and can give me some pros and cons of each.  

I think Ana's looks more like a traditional adirondack chair, but I am not sure it's as comfortable.  Ana's also looks like it makes better use of space (I'm not crazy about the dead space between the back and the arms on the Home Depot chair).  

Plus, I want to make a double (sofa) chair and am not sure which is easiest to convert to sofa without losing stability.  
 

Please let me know if you have any thoughts?

Thanks in advance.